Right, so first off, I'm not a researcher, and aside from a woeful few weeks in a lab as a medical student I've never done anything that could be properly described as research. ??I don't have the aptitude for it, for starters, and then there are a whole bunch of other reasons that I shouldn't be allowed in a lab…
I've been thinking a lot, though, about the use of the word "research" and how its use has shifted.??
A few examples, to illustrate what I mean, and deliberately extreme:
Watson/Crick, in the pub, circa 1953: ??"We've been researching the structure of DNA". ??Meaning????They've done some fairly serious thinking, mixed in with a bit of genius, playfulness, and come to an extraordinary insight.
Woodward/Bernstein, terrified and excited, circa 1972: ??"We've researched the goings on at Watergate and discovered that the president was lying". ??Meaning????Dogged hard work, persistence, luck and good use of a source. ??
My tutor to me as a student circa 1987, "An afternoon of research in a library can make you a local expert". ??Meaning????I'd got the critical facilities to be able to dissect an issue with a bit of reading around it. ??
Average anti-vaccine contributor to a website "I've researched vaccines, and they're bad". ??Meaning????I've googled it.
I have to say that I get this last one quite a lot from parents in clinic too.
Now, Google is an amazing thing . ??For example I can tell you, full of pretension, that only this afternoon I was trying to understand what a platonic solid was, and
Wikipedia helped me out in seconds. ??And, I reckon if you gave me another half hour with the website I could have a pretty good go at explaining to you what a platonic solid is. But this wasn't research. ??Not in any sense of the word. ??To go back to the vaccine example, any proper use of the word "research" with respect to vaccines would reveal that they're actually pretty good things. ??We should have a word for what I was doing – well, we've got lots, but none are that helpful. ??
We need to carve out and reserve the word "research" as a description of a deep understanding of an issue, and the ability to carry out critical thought in that area. ??Of course, this also implies that we need to equip many more ??people with the ability to carry out critical thoughts, which is perhaps the more important thing. ??And given that in the last week, three of the headlines in one of the red tops have been about someone apparently chucked off of the X factor TV show, I suspect that's not what those that sell us a lot of the information want us to develop. ??